- 1840 penny in fair condition: around $0.5-$1
- 1840 penny in good condition: around $2-$5
- 1840 penny in very fine condition: around $5-$10
- 1840 penny in extremely fine condition: around $15-$25
However, rare and valuable 1840 pennies may sell for much higher prices. It is always best to have a coin evaluated by a professional coin dealer or numismatist to determine its exact value.