The value of a 1935 Buffalo nickel depends on its condition and rarity. Common examples in circulated condition can sell for around $1, while higher-grade, uncirculated examples can fetch several hundred dollars or more. Some of the most valuable 1935 Buffalo nickels are the "Three-Legged Buffalo" and "Broken Arrow" varieties. The Three-Legged Buffalo variety features an extra leg on the bison's left side, while the Broken Arrow variety has a broken arrow on the bison's back. Both varieties are extremely rare and can sell for thousands of dollars.