History of North America

What was more responsible for the onset of war in US institution slavery or beliefs that states had right to secede from union?

While the enslavement of African Americans was certainly a significant factor in the outbreak of the Civil War, it is inaccurate to attribute the conflict solely to this institution. The war's origins are more complicated and involve other critical elements, including disagreements about states' rights, the expansion of slavery into new territories, and the growing divide between the Northern and Southern states over economic, social, and political issues.

Here are some of the important factors that led to the Civil War:

1. States' Rights: Many Southern states believed in states' rights, arguing that individual states had the right to make their own laws and control various aspects of their internal affairs without federal intervention. This belief clashed with the federal government's authority, particularly over issues such as slavery. Southern states feared that the federal government might eventually abolish slavery, which was crucial to their economy and social structure.

2. Expansion of Slavery: The debate over the expansion of slavery into new territories acquired by the United States led to heightened tensions between the North and the South. The admission of new states into the Union with or without slavery status became a contentious issue, with both sides fearing the potential loss of political power and the disruption of the balance of power in Congress.

3. Economic Differences: The North and the South had diverging economies. The North was experiencing industrialization, urbanization, and a growing manufacturing sector. In contrast, the Southern economy relied heavily on agriculture, particularly the cultivation of cotton, tobacco, and other cash crops, and was deeply dependent on slave labor. These economic differences created conflicts over issues like tariffs, internal improvements, and the distribution of federal resources.

4. Political Disunity: The Democratic and Republican parties, which were newly formed in the 1850s, were divided along sectional lines. The Democratic Party had strong support in the South, while the Republican Party gained prominence in the North. The parties had opposing views on slavery, states' rights, and other critical issues, contributing to political polarization.

5. The Election of 1860: The election of Abraham Lincoln as president in 1860 was the final straw for many Southern states. Lincoln, a member of the Republican Party, was seen as a threat to the institution of slavery and states' rights. His victory prompted several Southern states to secede from the Union, leading to the outbreak of the Civil War.

In conclusion, while slavery was a crucial factor in the Civil War, it was not the sole cause of the conflict. Various other factors, including states' rights, the expansion of slavery, economic differences, political disunity, and the election of 1860, all played significant roles in leading to the outbreak of war.