- 1913-1938 (Common Date): $2 - $5
- 1926-S: $150
- 1936-D 3-Legged or "Tripod" Buffalo: $100 - $230
Buffalo Commemoratives:
- 2001 Buffalo Gold Dollar (1 oz. gold): $1,900 - $2,250
- 2006 Platinum Eagle Reverse Proof Buffalo: $1,500 - $2,200
- 2005-W "Westward Journey" Buffalo Silver Dollar (1 oz. silver): $100 - $185
- 1997-P Silver Commemorative Buffalo Round: $16 - $22
- 1995-W Proof Buffalo Round: $14 - $20
Buffalo Bullion:
- 1 oz. Gold Buffalo: $1,850 - $1,950
- 1 oz. Silver Buffalo: $35 - $45