- Death: In many cases, stealing a shilling could be punished by death. This was especially true if the theft was committed against a church or a member of the nobility.
- Mutilation: Offenders might have their hands or ears cut off as punishment for theft.
- Whipping: Thieves could be publicly whipped as a form of punishment.
- Imprisonment: Offenders might be imprisoned for a period of time, sometimes for life.
- Fines: In some cases, thieves could be ordered to pay a fine as punishment.
- Banishment: Thieves could be banished from their community or town as a form of punishment.
The specific punishment for stealing a shilling would also depend on factors such as the offender's age, social status, and prior criminal record. In general, the punishments for theft were more severe during the early medieval period and became somewhat more lenient in later medieval times.