Arguments for US support of the French Revolution
* Ideological affinity: The French Revolution was inspired by Enlightenment ideals of liberty, equality, and fraternity, which were also foundational principles of the American Revolution. Many in the US, particularly those involved in the American Revolution, sympathized with the revolutionaries' cause and believed in supporting their struggle.
* Revolutionary solidarity: The US had received significant support from France during its own revolutionary war against Britain. Some, including Thomas Jefferson, believed that it owed France a debt and should repay it by providing assistance to the French revolutionaries.
* Weakening of Britain: By supporting the French, the US could potentially weaken its former enemy, Great Britain, and ensure its own long-term security. This line of thought considered Britain as a threat to US interests and saw an opportunity to counter British power by bolstering France.
Arguments against US support of the French Revolution
* Neutrality: Many Americans, particularly President George Washington and Secretary of State Thomas Jefferson (at least initially), believed it was in the US's best interests to remain neutral in the conflict. They wanted to avoid entanglement in European wars, which could divert resources and damage the country's own stability and development.
* Economic concerns: The US was heavily involved in trade with both Britain and France, and there were fears that siding with one side would jeopardize economic relations with the other. Neutrality allowed the US to continue trading with both parties and safeguard its commercial interests.
* Domestic turmoil: The US was still grappling with internal challenges, including financial difficulties, political divisions, and the issue of slavery. Many believed it should focus on its own affairs rather than getting involved in foreign conflicts.
In the end, the US government decided to maintain a policy of neutrality, as outlined in the Neutrality Proclamation of 1793. This allowed the country to avoid direct conflict and preserve its trade relations, while at the same time avoiding the risk of being drawn into a protracted European war. Nevertheless, the decision also drew criticism from those who felt the US should have played a more active role in supporting the French revolutionaries.
It's important to note that the US's position was not entirely static, and there were individuals within the government who held differing views on the issue. As the French Revolution became increasingly radical, some grew more critical of its excesses, and support for involvement diminished.