There are currently three known 1860 Indian Head pennies or “No S” (no mint mark) cent:
* 1860-O - Judd-113: Currently, there is only one known genuine Judd-113. In September of 2021, it sold for $204,000 at a Heritage Auction. However, several counterfeit “Judd-113” coins exist, and you should be cautious if any are offered for sale.
* 1860-P - Judd-120: The most expensive and rare 1860 Indian Head penny is the 1860-P Judd-120. The sole 1860-P Judd-120 cent sold for $1.65 million at a Stack’s Bowers Galleries sale in June 2021, setting the record for the highest price ever paid for an Indian Head cent.
* 1860-P/O - Judd-130: There is only one known 1860-P/O Judd-130 cent, making it the rarest and second-most valuable of the three. In 1995, it sold for $198,000 at a Bowers and Merena Coin Auction.